Question

 
There are 2 candidates for rabbi in the community.
1. Not honest.
2. Doesn't know how to think and doesn't know how to learn Torah, although he does have some kind of ordination.
 
Candidate 1 doesn't recognize his own deficiency.
Candidate 2 doesn't recognize his own deficiency, speaks with great confidence, and is caught out many times in ignorance, superficiality, and lack of understanding.
 
Whom should one choose?