Q&A: The Unique Quality of Israel
Originally published:
This is an English translation (via GPT-5.4). Read the original Hebrew version.
The Unique Quality of Israel
Question
In the trilogy you wrote about the Kuzari’s remarks on the unique quality of Israel, and you wondered where the Kuzari got the idea that only Jews are capable of attaining prophecy..
In scholarship, see for example the introduction by Daniel Lasker to Michael Schwarz’s translation of the Kuzari, where they argue that the source is Shi’ite Islam, which attributes a special quality to the Shi’ite imams, and their special quality is expressed through prophecy.
Answer
I don’t recall asking that. What I wondered was where he got the idea that Israel has a unique quality beyond the rest of humanity. Claims like this one, about external influence, usually strike me as dubious.