חדש באתר: NotebookLM עם כל תכני הרב מיכאל אברהם. דומה למיכי בוט.

Q&A: Telling a Non-Jew on Sunday When It Is Sabbath for Him

Back to list  |  🌐 עברית  |  ℹ About
Originally published:
This is an English translation (via GPT-5.4). Read the original Hebrew version.

Telling a Non-Jew on Sunday When It Is Sabbath for Him

Question

Have a good week, Rabbi,
Is there any problem with telling a non-Jew to do some kind of prohibited labor over the internet when it is Sunday where I am, but Sabbath where he is? For example, suppose there is some online computer game and I ask the non-Jew to perform some action in the game on my Saturday night, while for the non-Jew it is still Sabbath. Is there any issue with that?
Best regards,

Answer

You can search online. The later halakhic authorities have discussed this.
In my opinion, no. First, there are views that saying during the weekday to do something on Sabbath is not prohibited at all (if the prohibition is because of “speaking of such matters” and not because of agency to a non-Jew, as a stringency. There is a contradiction in Rashi on this). Second, logically, when for you it is a weekday and the non-Jew is in another country where it is Sabbath, this is less severe than telling a non-Jew on Friday eve to desecrate the Sabbath. Logic suggests that the determining day is your day, not his (since you are the one obligated to observe the Sabbath). One should remember that this is a rabbinic prohibition (apparently even lighter than an ordinary rabbinic prohibition), and therefore in a case of doubt one may be lenient.
If you benefit from the results, this could be considered an act done on Sabbath, and that is already a somewhat different issue (though here too, in my opinion, there is room to be lenient).

Discussion on Answer

Oren (2023-07-01)

And if we're talking about a secular Jew rather than a non-Jew, would the answer change?

Michi (2023-07-01)

Yes. That Jew is violating the Sabbath from his own standpoint. There it is certainly his Sabbath that determines things. True, in my view an atheist is not subject to commandments or transgressions, but that is only regarding causing him to stumble. Your telling him is not merely causing him to stumble; it turns his act into something done for you and because of you.

השאר תגובה

Back to top button