Q&A: A decree? Or simply basic fairness?
A decree? Or simply basic fairness?
Question
It was just published that they’re continuing with the “decrees”…
The Minister for the Development of the Negev and the Galilee announced that until now [Minister Deri], 86% of the budget went to subsidizing trips for yeshivot… and now he is changing that. So the headline is that this is a “decree”…
And I’m wondering: this is a ministry that is supposed to develop the Negev and the Galilee, so how can it be that 86% of the budget goes to trips for yeshivot? After all, the yeshivot are not 86% of the taxpayers… nor are they 86% of the people. How can it be that such a small percentage of the public receives the overwhelming majority of the money?
That really seems unfair. If so, the new minister is doing something very commendable by stopping this injustice [in my humble opinion]. So why is this called a decree? On the contrary, this is exactly the commandment of “and you shall do what is right and good”…
Does it seem to the honorable Rabbi that I’m right, or mistaken?
Answer
You are certainly right.
Do you have a link to that announcement? It sounds exaggerated.
Discussion on Answer
That’s 86% of the trips budget, not of the ministry’s entire budget.
The trips budget, indeed.
As for the little dirty tricks in other budgets, I don’t know anything about that… but there’s a presumption…?
It’s also not 86% of the ministry’s trips budget, but 60%. It’s a ministry project whose purpose is to allow students to get to know the Galilee.
https://m.calcalist.co.il/Article.aspx?guid=39119710
"Unlike the Haredi students, whose trips lasted one day, the trips for the other sectors lasted three days and therefore cost more. The funding for a non-Haredi student’s trip was 433 shekels, while for a Haredi student it was 115 shekels. But even when one checks the budgetary cost, it turns out that the Haredi trips cost 5.3 million shekels, 1.5 times the cost of the trips for non-Haredi students, which came to 3.6 million shekels. In other words, yeshiva students received 60% of the budget even though they make up only one fifth of the relevant population."
The 86% is the percentage of Haredi students who participated in this program out of all the students who took part in it (53,300). Haredi students make up about 21% of all students in the post-elementary education system.
I’m not claiming that the situation in the Ministry for the Periphery and the Galilee was necessarily proper, but it’s sometimes worth getting into the details and not being dazzled by the headlines. Especially since there are probably other budgets whose main beneficiaries are דווקא the non-Haredim.
With God’s help, eve of Rosh Chodesh Av 5781
School trips to the Galilee and the Negev help their economic development, since every educational institution that comes to those regions pays for food, lodging, and entrance to sites, and the tens of thousands of students traveling there contribute to the economic cultivation of those regions. In this respect there is no difference between secular, Religious Zionist, or Haredi travelers. Every group of travelers contributes to the growth and strengthening of the region.
The fact that the Haredi share of trips to the Galilee and the Negev is greater than their share of the population teaches us the troubling fact that the secular public is growing more distant from traveling in these areas. It turns out that secular Israelis are becoming psychologically detached from the periphery, and for them the State of Israel is increasingly shrinking into the “ghetto” of “between Hadera and Gedera.” If this process continues, God forbid, we will find ourselves in a situation where the Galilee and the Negev cease to be part of our consciousness as part of the Land of Israel.
The solution should be to increase encouragement for state schools, and perhaps even obligate them, to take more trips in the Galilee and the Negev, as the poet said: “Rise and walk through the land with backpack and staff, and surely along the way you will once again find the Land of Israel. The fields of the good land will accompany you; it will call you to it like to a cradle of love.” Traveling in the Galilee and the Negev will strengthen the youth’s connection and love for these parts of the country.
With blessings, Azriel Tzemach Halevi Kalisher
Paragraph 1, line 3
… every group of travelers contributes…
Paragraph 2, line 1
… that the Haredi share of trips to the Galilee and the Negev…
Only a naive person thinks that other parties do not use similar methods, and the Torah-study settlement cores funded by the Ministry of Agriculture are just one example out of many.
https://www.bhol.co.il/news/1247360