Q&A: Is it right to consult sages in areas outside their expertise, such as going to war
Originally published:
This is an English translation (via GPT-5.4). Read the original Hebrew version.
Is it right to consult sages in areas outside their expertise, such as going to war
Question
Answer
It is worthwhile to consult with anyone, especially with wise people. What to accept and what to reject is, of course, for you to decide yourself.
Discussion on Answer
Why not?
But the Rabbi himself argues that if the rabbi being asked is not knowledgeable in the field of the question being asked, it is not right to consult him—certainly not when it is a question of whether to go to war, just as the Rabbi gave the example from the coronavirus period.
Do you want me to repeat myself again? As I wrote, it is worthwhile to consult with any wise person, even in areas that are not his expertise. It is worth investing a minute to think before asking a question.
Forgive me, but I do not know whether my question was received, so I will ask again: Maimonides claims that one may not go out to an optional war unless they consult the Sanhedrin. Is that not true for our times as well?