Q&A: Six Hundred Thousand in a Public Domain
Originally published:
This is an English translation (via GPT-5.4). Read the original Hebrew version.
Six Hundred Thousand in a Public Domain
Question
What is the Rabbi’s view of Rashi’s reasoning that there is no public domain without six hundred thousand? As is known, this reasoning has no source in the Talmud and contradicts common sense, and yet Ashkenazim have nevertheless been lenient on the basis of it. As part of the Rabbi’s approach of ruling from first principles, should we return and be stringent in accordance with the plain meaning of Jewish law, that a road 16 cubits wide is a public domain?
Answer
I am not well-versed in this topic, but in principle, yes.