חדש באתר: NotebookLM עם כל תכני הרב מיכאל אברהם

Q&A: Benefit from Sabbath Desecration

Back to list  |  🌐 עברית  |  ℹ About
Originally published:
This is an English translation (via GPT-5.4). Read the original Hebrew version.

Benefit from Sabbath Desecration

Question

Is there any particular prohibition against watching videos on YouTube that were uploaded/filmed on the Sabbath? Or perhaps one has to wait a certain amount of time? Is there a difference between Sabbath desecration by Jews and by non-Jews?
And, similarly, is there any prohibition against asking a question on some forum before the Sabbath and then reading the answer on Saturday night? (Again, regarding waiting a certain amount of time and the difference between Jews and non-Jews.)

Answer

In any case, it is permitted on Saturday night, but if it was done by a non-Jew one must wait the amount of time needed for it to be done—that is, the time it takes to film the video. The same applies to the question as well.

Discussion on Answer

Oren (2025-07-27)

I saw the following written on Google:
A non-Jew’s Sabbath handiwork that was not done for me—that is, Sabbath work done by a non-Jew without any request or involvement from a Jew, and not intended for him—is permitted for use by the Jew. The prohibition of “Sabbath handiwork” applies only when the non-Jew did the act especially for the Jew, or when the Jew asked him to do it.

In the present case, based on this, could one permit watching the video without waiting the amount of time needed for it to be done?

Michi (2025-07-27)

Simply speaking, such a situation is considered as having been done for you, because he does it for all the viewers/customers.

Harel (2025-07-28)

In a case of loss, is it enough just to wait the amount of time needed for it to be done? For example, a peeled potato will blacken and be ruined while waiting until Saturday night, and some wicked fellow comes along and bakes it in the oven on the Sabbath. On Saturday night, after waiting the amount of time needed for it to be done, may one eat it? If they had waited until Saturday night, the potato would have been ruined. Does that make a difference?

Noam (2025-07-28)

In cases like these, what counts as the amount of time needed for it to be done? After all, some videos can sometimes take weeks of work (production, editing, etc.).

Michi (2025-07-28)

Noam, the question is how much time was devoted to it on the Sabbath, not how long it takes to create a video. The idea is that you should not profit from Sabbath desecration.

Harel, one can argue it either way. In a rabbinic-level doubt, one rules leniently.

Leave a Reply

Back to top button