Q&A: The Laws of Zimun
Originally published:
This is an English translation (via GPT-5.4). Read the original Hebrew version.
The Laws of Zimun
Question
1. Does the Rabbi say the blessing “Who nourishes” out loud when leading a zimun? 2. I understood that in the Rabbi’s view, a secular Jew who does not believe in the obligation of the commandments from Sinai does not count toward a minyan. Is that correct? By the same logic, do we also not recite zimun with him? 3. Why do Ashkenazim not include a minor for zimun? I understood that the ruling in the Talmud is almost explicit (Rabbi Nachman) that he is included?
Answer
- I try to.
- Very much so.
- https://ph.yhb.org.il/10-05-09/